Why Does Ontario Fund Catholic Schools But Not Other Private Schools?

Direct answer

Ontario funds Roman Catholic schools because section 93 of the Constitution Act, 1867 protected separate-school rights at Confederation, before the Charter existed. In Adler v. Ontario (1996) the Supreme Court held that funding Catholic schools and not others does not breach the Charter, because Charter rights cannot be used to attack section 93. Ontario provides no direct public funding to private schools of any kind.

Page updated · Sources

Prefer to watch? See all short explainers

The numbers behind the answer

Constitutional basis
Section 93, 1867
Constitution Act, 1867
Charter challenge
Rejected, 1996
Adler v. Ontario, [1996] 3 S.C.R. 609
Funding for private schools
None
Government of Ontario

The constitutional reason

When Ontario joined Confederation in 1867, section 93 of the Constitution Act protected the school rights that Roman Catholic separate-school supporters already held. Those rights predate the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms by 115 years. Catholic school boards are therefore not private schools at all - they are publicly funded, publicly governed school boards with elected trustees, and they carry the same special education duties as public boards, including the IPRC process, Individual Education Plans, and a Special Education Advisory Committee.

Private schools sit outside that structure entirely. Ontario treats them as independent businesses or non-profits. They receive no direct provincial funding, and they are not bound by most of the Education Act machinery that protects students with disabilities.

Three ways the asymmetry has been challenged

Families who wanted funding for Jewish and Christian schools took the question to the Supreme Court of Canada. In Adler v. Ontario, [1996] 3 S.C.R. 609, the Court held that funding Catholic schools and not others does not breach Charter sections 2(a) or 15(1), because Charter guarantees cannot be used to attack rights that section 93 itself confers.

They then took it internationally. In Waldman v. Canada (Communication No. 694/1996, decided 5 November 1999), the UN Human Rights Committee found that Ontario had violated Article 26 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, holding that funding one religious group and not another must rest on reasonable and objective criteria. The Committee's views are not binding in Canadian law. Ontario did not change its funding. Finally, in 2007, Progressive Conservative leader John Tory campaigned on extending funding to other faith-based schools; the party lost the election and Tory lost his own seat. No Ontario party has campaigned on it since.

What this means if you are paying private school tuition

There is no current Ontario government proposal to fund private schools. Proposals do exist from policy organizations, and they frequently begin with students who have special education needs, but none has become policy and no party platform in 2018, 2022 or 2025 committed to one.

The more immediate point for families is that funding is not the only thing missing at a private school. There is no IPRC, no requirement to write an Individual Education Plan, no Special Education Advisory Committee, and no appeal to the Ontario Special Education Tribunal. The Ontario Human Rights Code does still apply, because a private school provides a service, so disability discrimination remains actionable at the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario.

This page is general information about how Ontario law is structured. It is not legal advice, and it is not a comment on any particular school or case. For advice on your own situation, contact the Human Rights Legal Support Centre or ARCH Disability Law Centre.

Ten steps · four phases

See every school step before choosing your next one.

This overview shows the order of the main routes. The detailed guide below explains what happens, what parents can request, and which records to keep at each stage.

  1. Phase 01

    Prepare for school

    Complete the clinical and transition work before the first school day.

    1. 1 Diagnosis and OAP registration
    2. 2 OAP Entry to School program
    3. 3 Kindergarten transition
  2. Phase 02

    Put supports in writing

    Move from informal conversations to a documented placement and support plan.

    1. 4 IPRC identification
    2. 5 IEP development
    3. 6 EA support request
  3. Phase 03

    Escalate when support stalls

    Use the next formal route only when the school-level process has not resolved the issue.

    1. 7 SEAC deputation
    2. 8 OSET appeal
    3. 9 HRTO complaint
  4. Phase 04

    Plan the next transition

    Use the IEP transition plan to connect school with the path after secondary education.

    1. 10 Post-secondary transition

The path is not always linear. Start with the phase that matches your child’s current situation, then use the linked guide for the exact request, record, or appeal route.

Frequently asked questions

Are Catholic schools in Ontario private schools?

No. Catholic school boards are publicly funded and publicly governed, with elected trustees, and they carry the same special education obligations as public boards under the Education Act. Their funding is constitutionally protected by section 93 of the Constitution Act, 1867.

Who funds Catholic schools in Ontario?

The province does. Catholic school boards are publicly funded and publicly governed, with elected trustees. Their right to funding traces to section 93 of the Constitution Act, 1867, and Ontario provides no direct funding to private schools.

When did Catholic schools become publicly funded in Ontario?

Separate-school rights were protected at Confederation in 1867. Full public funding of Catholic secondary schools came later, through Bill 30, which the Supreme Court of Canada upheld in Reference re Bill 30 ([1987] 1 S.C.R. 1148) as a valid use of the province’s power under section 93.

Did the UN really rule against Ontario on school funding?

Yes. In 1999 the UN Human Rights Committee found in Waldman v. Canada that funding Catholic but not other religious schools violated Article 26 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. However, the Committee's views are not binding in Canadian law, and Ontario did not change its funding.

Is Ontario planning to fund private schools?

There is no current government proposal. No Ontario PC platform in 2018, 2022 or 2025 mentioned funding independent schools, vouchers or education savings accounts, and we found no government or private member's bill that would create them.

Sources

  1. Constitution Act, 1867

    Section 93 - provincial power over education, subject to protection of denominational school rights existing at Confederation

  2. Adler v. Ontario

    Adler v. Ontario, [1996] 3 S.C.R. 609 (1996 CanLII 148) - Supreme Court of Canada

  3. Waldman v. Canada

    UN Human Rights Committee, Communication No. 694/1996, UN Doc. CCPR/C/67/D/694/1996 (5 November 1999)

  4. Reference re Bill 30

    Reference re Bill 30, An Act to Amend the Education Act (Ont.), [1987] 1 S.C.R. 1148 - full funding for Roman Catholic separate secondary schools upheld

    Checked

Next steps

Keep going with related guidance, tools, and evidence.

About this page

Check the author’s context, review method, and how to report an error.

Written by Spencer Carroll

Founder & Autism Advocate

Lived experience: Parent of autistic child in the OAP system